A Geography of Displacement: Siddhartha Menon's Lone Pine

Siddhartha Menon’s latest poetry collection, Lone Pine, reads like a meditation on the inherent discomfort of existing between worlds. Spanning 68 poems, it explores topography, time, and shifting identities, navigating the treacherous terrain between belonging and displacement to reveal how the very notion of “home” may be fundamentally at odds with our lived experience.

The titular poem establishes the central metaphor with startling clarity. Here is a tree that shouldn't exist where it does, yet persists with stubborn grace. The poet walks past it daily, touching "its toughness," witnessing its perpetual shedding of needles that "cover dust and flatness with the scent of resin slopes." The poem's devastating conclusion that "home is out of place" reverberates throughout the collection, suggesting that displacement is not an aberration but a fundamental condition of existence.

What distinguishes Menon's work is his extraordinary ability to find the universal in the utterly specific. "The Lesson" transforms the mundane observation of a fallen tree into a profound meditation on mortality and the hidden decay that exists within apparent stability. The tree's "stealthy eating from inside" becomes a metaphor for the ways we all harbor our own destruction, while its eventual fall offers not tragedy but transformation: "What is left is for a tree to be imagined as it once was / for us to receive in its place the sun."

Menon's eye for the natural world is matched by his sensitivity to human rhythms and rituals. In "Keeping Time," the choreography of peahens, dogs, fishermen, and women in bright veils creates a symphony of movement where "Nothing will slow them down / but they will find it hard to speed things up." The poem captures something essential about the persistence of traditional life in the face of an accelerating world.

The treatment of seasonal disruption in "A Cool Morning in Summer" demonstrates poet's ability to compress environmental anxiety into just a few lines. The image of leaves "driven right up to the door" and clouds "positioned ahead of time" suggests a world slightly out of joint, where natural cycles can no longer be trusted. The poem's final question - about summer flowers withering early and migrating birds staying put lingers with contemporary relevance.

Menon's preoccupation with temporality reaches its most sophisticated expression in the four-part sequence "Time in four nutshells." Here, time becomes both adversary and companion, something to be killed, raced against, and ultimately transcended. In "Racing Against Time," the personification is particularly striking: time "comes metronomically / and goes," while observers place "illicit bets / on a showdown between time and will." The sequence's final movement, "Ahead Of time," confronts mortality with characteristic directness: "Death is untimely / even when it was the best alternative." The recognition that "Something always remains to be said" captures the essential incompleteness of human existence.

Perhaps most moving are the poems that deal with artistic creation and literary community. "Seeing becomes a poem" transforms an encounter with jackals and a nilgai into a meditation on the act of poetic observation itself. When the delicate balance of watching and being watched collapses, the speaker finds himself "on a pile of words" that are "tattered almost poetic." It's a perfect metaphor for how experience becomes art- messy, imperfect, but somehow necessary.

The multi-part "Literary event" sequence offers a particularly intimate glimpse into the awkward dance of literary community. The description of "three local men (the moderators) / three foreign women (two novelists, a poet)" captures the well-meaning but often stilted nature of cultural exchange. When the speaker receives the visiting poet's book, the experience becomes one of trying to find common ground across languages: "Perhaps this is a way you too will go / though it leads to the edge of a northern sea."

In "Amaltas," the contrast between the tree's "yellow exquisiteness" and its "torso flaked and mottled like skin with old burns" creates a powerful metaphor for beauty emerging from damage. The image of "a blacksmith / dripping lines of poetry" is particularly striking, suggesting that art requires both fire and precision.

Equally impressive is Menon's ability to find poetry in the mundane machinery of modern life. "Road roller" transforms a construction vehicle into something almost mythological, with its "red lights flashing / and lamps sticking out of the cab like eyes." The poem's conclusion, where the speaker becomes "the earth's tremor" as the machine passes, exemplifies Menon's gift for finding moments of surprising intimacy with an increasingly mechanized world.

The collection's religious and political dimensions are handled with admirable subtlety. "Teens on Shravan Monday" captures the vitality of young pilgrims navigating "unholy muck" in a "smart city whose time has been coming since the inception of time." Meanwhile, "mosque and temple" confronts communal tension with dark humor and genuine anguish, as "barriers cannot contain" the "bloodlust" that finds "outlet" in a world where "history is a hooker."

If there's a criticism to be made, it might be that some poems feel slightly undercooked-moments where poet's natural restraint prevents him from fully exploring an image or idea. But this same restraint is often what makes his work so powerful. He trusts his readers to complete the emotional circuit, to understand that sometimes the most profound truths are best approached obliquely.

This is work that rewards careful reading and rereading, poems that reveal new layers of meaning with each encounter. In a time when displacement- whether physical, cultural, or psychological- seems to be the defining experience of modernity, Menon offers not easy comfort but something more valuable: the recognition that we are not alone in our essential homelessness, and that there is a strange beauty to be found in learning to live with that fact.

The collection suggests that perhaps the lone pine's apparent displacement is actually a form of belonging we don't yet understand- that being "out of place" might be the most honest way to inhabit our complicated world. In Menon's hands, this becomes not a cause for despair but a source of unexpected grace.

---